Miguel Ponce de Leon

Irish and EU research on Future Internet, Living Labs, IP Mobility, Security and Autonomic Network Management.

« The Internet of Thingemebobs | Main | FP6 has MORE than come to a close »

September 6, 2009

Digitising health records is it really going to be helpful?

I hear again and again all the positives about eHealthcare, it's seems to be the only way to go, which is why I've found this OA paper asking a very interesting question "Do Electronic Health Records Help or Hinder Medical Education?" and I wonder in the same way will electronic health records help or hinder (my) medical anaylsis in the future?

Photo Credit: JasonRogersFooDogG iraffeBee's photostream on flickr http://www.flickr.com/photos/restlessglobetrotter/
It is becoming clear that hospitals are implementing, and in some ways are being forced to implement massive electronic health record (EHR) systems, but in this implementation are they considering the end user .... sorry I should say patients needs, wants and cares in its implementation? And what about the people entrying the data from admin staff to nurses to doctors, are their needs being considered?
On similar massive projects it simply hasn't been the case and I do wonder!

So to the powers that be, please note the authors conclusion when it comes to the educational side of using EHR

that the mere presence of the EHR will not improve practice quality, and will not make education better or more efficient .........
.......... if the EHR is used as a tool rather than an end unto itself, it will improve our education of young physicians as well as the care of our patients.

Posted by miguelpdl at September 6, 2009 10:39 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.tssg.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/220

Comments

I think the benefits are in cases where your medical records live in one hospital but you need to be treated at another.

I've known friends to be in a situation where treatment can't start because letters need to be sent and received before the request for data can happen.

Presumably, with electronic records, this isn't as much of a problem -- though it's a fair point to ask if a multi-billion software project is the right approach, where even a fax machine could probably speed things up by days.

Posted by: Brian White at September 7, 2009 12:40 AM

Agreed that tech. change without human and procedural change will result in no change.

But I do think there is something to be said for simple tech. advancements in health care. I went to the doctor the other week for the first time in 15 years. I didn't know my blood group, my last blood test results, what my allergies were called, any drug issues I might have, the age at which I had had meningitis or if I had had German measles and so on.

Then there were all the non-medial, personal details, PSRI number, address, parent details, spouse details etc. that I had to provide. Also any medical history with my family and so on.

Most of the info I had to look up on my iPhone on the spot. Searching old emails, sending a quick message to my parents and fianceƩ etc.

This reminds me of those simple bracelets high-risk people used to wear. It had their major allergies and health problems listed on them in case of an emergency when the person was unable to communicate.

Pushing that idea forward might be worth something. A stick of memory I carry around with me that I can present to my doctor and that has all my relevant details on it. Maybe a simple display on it so that it doesn't require a reader and can be used on the spot in an emergency.

Then again I didn't see a single computer in the doctor's office I went too. It was all paper based.

Posted by: Paul M. Watson at September 8, 2009 3:00 PM

@Brian White
Yes I agree, and just to add in this case I'd prefer to own/host my own EHR(s), thus allowing hospital A and hospital B to access my records off of my own hosted service. All that hospital A would have to do is instruct hospital B that it should access my record, hopefully a billion euros is not needed for this approach. In fact this is has made me look and I might go for OpenEHR http://www.openehr.org/home.html

@Paul M. Watson
Sounds like you're ready for Google Health https://www.google.com/health is there an app for that?

Posted by: Miguel Ponce de Leon at September 17, 2009 11:40 PM

We are a little over two years into our EMR implementation and although we have had some growing pains, we are already reaping the rewards of having digital information. Not having to look for missing charts on a patient with an urgent problem (not to mention being able to view a patient's record from home!), drug-drug interactions, drug allergies...these are but a few of many advantages of having an electronic record. Once the novelty wears off, then maybe we will see some otherwise true improvements in the delivery of health care as you point out.

Posted by: Medical Practice Trends at July 27, 2010 3:55 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?